Web Analytics Made Easy - Statcounter

Portfolio Categories Positive Inflections

We knew Victoria’s Secret (VSXY): Reduced Promotions!

For months prior to yesterday’s massive 45% inflection, our promotional ensemble revealed sharp behavioral changes in how Victoria’s Secret was connecting with leads. Our systems were tracking sharp reductions in email campaigns and sending volumes typically associated with robust organic demand.

When brands see strong responses to new product offerings, they can reduce reliance on push email campaigns. Our systems tracking volumes of promotional emails to real VS customers and leads tipped our investor partners toward to soon to be announced massive beat and raise.

Specifically our steep discount index declined over 35% as VS sent fewer 40% off discounts. Our ‘desperation’ index also retreated lower as VS needed fewer incentives such as “extra 10%” or “free”. In the first half of the year VS send nearly 200 fewer email campaigns than PY!

Not to our surprise, this promotion shift resulted in a 240 basis point expansion in the gross margins with notable strength in merchandize margins and greater full priced selling . At Random Walk, our investor partners have been alerted to this outlier but through our data feeds and specific call outs.

Victoria’s secret further validated our conclusions by specifically citing a “promo detox” strategy that reduces promotions and markdowns in favor of “compelling emotional messages” to drive a healthier, brand-led

Has Chipotle’s Spring Marketing Strategy Driven Engagement?

We married our campaign search data repository and asked Claude:

CMG: Leveraging Random Walk w/Claude
Connecting Email Campaigns to Assess Organic Demand

Random Walk Campaign Search Allows Ingestion of Any Email Marketing Promotion
Our new web dashboard allows downloading of nearly 400 brands email marketing campaigns for analysis.  Below, we uploaded all campaigns for Chipotle for March-April 2026 and the prior year

We then uploaded these key marketing campaigns to Claude and asked how effective campaigns were at driving mobile traffic.

Below: Using Claude paired with Random Walk & Similarweb, we can see Chipotle has substantially modified their promotional strategy this spring.

RH: Demand Rollover Revealed

RH: Promotional Email March Madness
MARCH 31, 2026Restoration Hardware (RH) reported  worse than expected sales, earnings and provided a tepid outlook. 

Since our system uncovered and alerted investors to the inflection in late January, shares have collapsed 50%.

Most aligned with our process, RH guided Q1 revenues nearly $90 mm below consensus.   Our promotional ensemble revealed a reversal in the controlled promotional volumes we tracked late last year.   This Spring, we uncovered rapidly ramping campaign volumes and discounting language.  Instead of 1-2 campaigns a week, in March we tracked near daily push offers.  

Intensity also ramped, with our systems capturing escalating language with more 70% discounts, culminating in near daily offers the past 14 days. 

 Random Walk Promotional Dashboard
As can be seen below, our ensemlbe triggered a code ‘red’ incicating steep 70% or higher discount language in the subject line. 

Reviewing Key Indices
As can be seen below investors receiving our weekly index data were alerted to sharp deviations in two key indices: Total, and Steep,

  • Total Index after several quarters of stability ramped back above PY levels
  • Steep Index further validated a change in how management was viewing demand.

 ‘March Madness’ Promotional Calendar 
Our heat map detects the explosive growth in blasts and campaign frequency to leads with a disastrous end of March panic

Unprecedented Discounts Help Predict Weak Outlooks

The signal we are typically most focused on providing our investor partners is when brands change how they communicate with their leads and customers. Ramping up email marketing is often the cheapest and easiest way to engage customers. When brands are struggling, instead of posting a discount publicly on the website, they can target specific segments and cohorts.

For the case of brands like Crocs, we see this often in the form of “we miss you” type emails. Growth in these type of emails helped us uncover a structural slowdown in demand for Crocs in the Unites States.

Above we note that prior to 2024, Crocs never sent these type of storewide 30% off coupons. This inflection was missed by the street because transactional data, and website scraping failed to detect this behavioral change.

Looking at another example this year, we see below our our promotional ensemble detected new escalating discount intensity from Peloton. Despite noise about a turnaround and confidence to investors, behind the scenes management was escalting the discounts.

Above we see rare growth in $1500 off for Peleton bikes and treadmills.

Sometimes changes in keywords are more sutble. But this is often the most interesting use-case. Many premium brands present themselves as not having to discount. However, again, behind the scenes they are escalating their promotional intensity.

Here we can see Canada Goose, as they were likely noticing slack demand, they ramped their Winter promotional campaigns.

TPR: Coach continues hot streak as promos evaporate

Another unbelievably strong quarter from Tapestry as consumer preferences further shift towards Coach. This has been an exciting one for Random Walk as continued sharp declines in email promotional campaigns have predicted this robust growth.

From the time our system tracked declining volumes of clearance emails and steep discounts shares are now up more than 110%!

Today’s Q2 results featuring 25% growth in Coach and strong gains in margins further validate our mission: when brands see robust organic growth, they quickly respond by reducing promotional email campaigns.

Our new dashboard shows every critical category from significant discounts to our clearance index in sharp decline. What an outlier!

Bath & Body Works (BBWI) vs Walmart(WMT): Diverging Preferences Revealed

With rampant inflation continuing to chew into consumers purchasing power, we continue to see a shift away from demand for discretionary knick-knacks towards critical household staples including food and clothing. The diverging promotional growth patterns in BBWI and WMT make this trend apparent.

>  BBWI forecast high single digit declines for the critical Q4 holiday quarter, noting a challenging  start to holiday shopping beginning in Q3 … highly competitive environment”.

>. BBWI management’s final comment directly aligns the the email campaigns we tracked “…our customers are waiting for deeper discounts before making purchases.”

Gross Profit Rate declined  220 basis points as management noted “increased promotional activity to clear inventory”.

Walmart (WMT) vs Bath & Body Works (BBWI) Not all retailers are exploding their promotional campaigns and email volumes.  As seen below WMT total volumes actually declined into peak shopping season as consumer preferences shifted towards cost effective core needs and away from discretionary scented candles and bubbles..

We captured explosive growth in 75% off campaigns from BBWI

Additionally BBWI was forced to grow BOGO campaigns by nearly 300%

Royal Caribbean RCL: Increased email campaigns precede revenue miss

>. Our promotional ensemble was successful in detecting the revenue miss and underwhelming guidance.
> In recent weeks total campaign volume has accelerated to new all-time highs.   
>Our index for  dollar amounts off and high dollar incentives have been above or near Black Friday levels for the past quarter. 

Steve discusses how our promotional ensemble revealed changes in how Royal was enticing cruisers

CMG, CAKE CAVA, CBRL, MCD, YUM: Unusual Email Campaigns

Our promotional ensemble was successful in detecting the inflection in Chipotle and Cava. As organic demand slowed both ‘bowl’ sellers began offering more and more freebies to their most loyal customers. Additionally, “new” product promotions and deals were send to a higher percentage of their lists. Instead of select targeted campaigns, massive blasts triggered our promotional ensemble.

Steve discussed the unusual activity in the restaurant sector

American Eagle, Sydney Sweeney & Email Discount Index

Steve discusses how the Random Walk Promotional Ensemble improved after the Sydney Sweeney campaign.

Systematic Scan of Millions of Emails to Detect Inflections

  • This week our system detected unusual activity in: CBRL, CRI, LEN, LULU, PZZA, SIG, ULTA, W
  • Our process helps discover brands that are struggling to move product and resorting to changing keywords in campaigns
  • Robust panel access helps reveal discounts sent to specific cohorts that are ‘invisible’ to coupon clippers on the sell-side
  • 8 year history enables comparisons vs other outlier periods such as COVID